You and Winter returned to your home and began the search. Was there any delay in that beginning? Winter sort of hints towards it, but you can put her off easily enough, should you wish to.
You search the place top to bottom, as much as you can. I assume you're being careful in Teddy's room? It's so disorganized anyway, it might not matter much. In any case you've pretty much lost hope that the knife is here.
You're still looking a few places. In fact where are you? There is a sudden rapid knock on the front door and someone calling your name.
When you go to answer it you find Riley there, her arm around a tearful Ashley who has her right hand cradled against her chest with a sweatshirt wrapped around it.
"I came to find out what was happening. She... she was sitting on the step."